Keep what you'll use

Last week JA Westenberg wrote about deleting thousands of notes and feeling relief, not loss. The collection had become, in Westenberg's words, a mausoleum: layers of systems, goals, and promises to a future self. We think the essay is right about what went wrong. We're less sure the only way out is to throw the notes away.

Westenberg put the problem in one line we keep coming back to:

> Structure is not thinking. Tags are not insights. Notes you never read again aren't really notes at all.

Anyone who has kept notes for a few years has felt some version of this. You save a passage, you file it, and you feel briefly in control. Then you never open it again. The pile grows. The thinking doesn't. In the first post in this series, Links should know why they exist, we called that the difference between a place that stores and a tool that helps you make something. Westenberg's essay is the same warning, written from the far side of a very large pile.

Deleting everything buys silence. It also deletes the sentence you wrote three years ago that would have unlocked today's page. The other way, the one we want MojoPad to take, is simpler to say than to build: keep what you'll use. Let notes come back when they have a job to do. Ask as little tending as you can. And never pretend that capture, by itself, is the work.

Only the dates you mean

The Timeline is the clearest picture of that rule. A page is on the line only when you gave it a date: Start and End in Page info, or a Date line at the top of the page. MojoPad never puts a page on the line on a guess. When a sentence already holds a date, that date waits under Not yet placed as a suggestion, with the sentence it came from, until you press Place. Pages with no date sit in the same list, so nothing quietly drops off. Looking at the Timeline changes nothing in your pages.

The line shows the dates your pages are about, not when you wrote them. A note you made yesterday about a battle in 1942 sits at 1942.

In this release you can also keep more than one view of that line. Choose… lets you pick which dated pages appear, and Save as… keeps that choice under a name, such as a research project or a family history. A short Saved list switches between them, with Show all still there when you want the whole line back. The pages you leave off are not deleted and not changed. They're only not drawn, and the choice is kept with the wiki.

That's the opposite of a system you have to rebuild each time you sit down.

A shelf, not a monument

Westenberg has a line about reading lists that landed close to home, because this release adds one:

> My ever-growing reading list became a monument to who I could be if I only read all those things I saved.

MojoPad's Reading list is a shelf with three piles: Want to read, Reading, and Read. Each book is an ordinary page, with a cover, a place for your own note, Recommended by, and a Book Link if you want to keep the store or library address. Paste a link or an ISBN, or type a title, and the details fill in. If you'd rather not look at it, turn off Show Reading list in Settings ▸ Sources. The book pages stay in the wiki, untouched.

We should be honest about what it does and doesn't do. Each pile shows how many books are in it. That's inventory, not a scoreboard: there is no unread badge, no streak, and no reminder that you ought to be reading more. The list will not nag you, and it will not prune itself. Why I want it is there if a reason would help you later. If the shelf stops being useful, you can hide it.

A list of books you mean to read can still become a monument. The app shouldn't help it along.

A link that takes you back to the words

Saving a quote is easy. Finding it again, in the page or the paper it came from, is the part that usually fails. In MojoPad you select the words, choose Copy Link to Selected Words, and paste. The words themselves become the link. Click them later and you land on that sentence, not merely the page it sat in.

The same idea works in a PDF. A highlight that other pages link to carries a small number at the edge of the page. The number is how many of your notes lean on that passage. Click it and you go to the note, with a line back to the highlight.

This is the opposite of filing a passage and never opening it. The quote stays attached to where it came from, and the path back is one click.

Days that remember you

The Journal is the same daily notes you already keep, shown as a single scrolling river, today at the top. At the top of today, a few quiet cards can appear. On this day brings back what you wrote on this date in years past. Worth revisiting offers a note your recent writing has drifted near. Carry over gathers unfinished to-dos so they don't fall off the bottom of the river. Each one can be dismissed for the day. Worth revisiting can also be turned off in Settings ▸ Journal. None of them is a streak.

This is as close as we come today to a promise that an old page can find you, instead of waiting for you to go hunting. It happens in the Journal, not everywhere, and only when it has something to show.

What we still don't do

We don't yet have a way to set a whole stack of old pages aside from your daily view, without deleting them, and bring them back when you want them. If the relief you're after is a quieter wiki, you still have to do some of that work yourself. We'd rather say so than pretend the app already curates your life.

We also won't claim that capture is useless. MojoPad still makes it easy to write something down and to link it as you type. The belief is about what happens after. A note that can come back in context is worth keeping. A note that only adds to a pile is how a mausoleum starts.

Keep what you'll use. The test for a notes app isn't how much it can hold. It's whether what you kept ever returns when it would help you think.

If you've been using MojoPad, you'll see more of this in 1.106.0: the Reading list, and named choices on the Timeline. If you think we've got something wrong, we'd honestly like to hear it.

‹ All posts